Ludlow Chamber of Trade issues dire warning on supermarket proposal

First published in News

LEADERS of Ludlow’s traders fear that if a new supermarket and petrol station is built on the outskirts of town it will be the death knell for many long established businesses.

The Ludlow Chamber of the Trade’s response follows a public consultation about a potential scheme to build a supermarket and petrol station on land at Rocks Green.

In a strongly worded response to the scheme Muff Murfin, chairman of the chamber, warns of dire consequences if the project were to go ahead.

The chamber believes that an out of town development would be in direct competition with shops in Ludlow.

“It challenges consumers’ shopping habits and will no doubt reduce footfall in the town centre,” said Muff Murfin.

“Once a supermarket has opened out of town it sets a precedent for further development which will increase the competition to a wider variety of shops currently trading in town.”

He claims that the Government has said that out of town retain development has ruined highs streets up and down the country and turned urban centres into ‘ghost or clone towns.’

“Ludlow’s marketing of the town is for its many small independent shops and its unique local food and drink offer will be jeopardised by a large retailer on the outskirts of town,” added Mr Murfin.

He said that Ludlow had done better than many other places because it opposed out of town development and nurtured local businesses.

“We recognise that money spent in the local independents reinforces the strength of the town’s economy and that spent in national conglomerates sucks money out of the town,” he added.

“There is a strong infrastructure of local producers and suppliers into these retailers that deliver quality and value for consumers who will be affected by national supply chains, and impact on the area around the town too.”

According to the Chamber of Trade, Ludlow has more than 100 independent businesses offering a wide range of services but many are operating on a knife edge.

“It will only take a small drop in turnover to endanger the profitability of these shops and therefore the inevitable closure of a number of them,” warned Mr Murfin.

“Does the town need another supermarket when there are three big ones in town and one medium one very close by with a petrol station? The town’s population is currently only around 10,000 and even with additional housing as planned this cannot be necessary.”

The chamber are suspicious of the claim that the new project would create 250 new jobs and believe that some of these must relate to the construction phase if the scheme were to go ahead.

“It is the view of the Ludlow Chamber of Trade and Commerce is that this proposal is threatening Ludlow’s town centre livelihood where many locals work in skilled professions for yet another supermarket which frankly has little in the way of a business case and interest in the town’s future,” added Mr Murfin.

“The unskilled and low paid jobs that may be created will be outweighed by the loss of higher paid work and jobs in the centre.”

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:26am Fri 18 Jul 14

scruffy Bandit says...

When Gateway it in a application people said the town would die.....It didn't
Tesco.....Ditto
Aldi........The same !
I love my town I am Ludlow born and bred but we need to move forward.Ludlow will continue to thrive and change which is natural progression. I believe people will stay to shop locally instead of travelling to Leominster and Hereford.....We need affordable food we can not all afford £2 for a Cauli.
People didn't try and stop the food centre for fear of loosing local Butchers,bakers or Green grocers.Stop feeding the ego's of the few and look after true local people.
Bring on a Supermarket !
When Gateway it in a application people said the town would die.....It didn't Tesco.....Ditto Aldi........The same ! I love my town I am Ludlow born and bred but we need to move forward.Ludlow will continue to thrive and change which is natural progression. I believe people will stay to shop locally instead of travelling to Leominster and Hereford.....We need affordable food we can not all afford £2 for a Cauli. People didn't try and stop the food centre for fear of loosing local Butchers,bakers or Green grocers.Stop feeding the ego's of the few and look after true local people. Bring on a Supermarket ! scruffy Bandit
  • Score: 2

6:34am Sat 19 Jul 14

Mark Ingle says...

During my lifetime I have seen all of the supermarkets come to Ludlow and each one has destroyed small businesses to the extent that ludlow now has more charity shops than food shops. It used to be the other way around.
I lived in the USA for many years and the one thing I hated was the chain superstores because they had no butchers, no bakers, no greengrocers, no independent restaurants. The choice and quality was sadly lacking as there is a limit to ones choices.
Even if one pays a little more to shop with a small trader you have to realise that quality of life and products is far better than quantity of products.
I for one will be very sad if yet another supermarket comes to town and closes another butcher / greengrocer and possible a baker. It will be a sad day for me and also for the community
During my lifetime I have seen all of the supermarkets come to Ludlow and each one has destroyed small businesses to the extent that ludlow now has more charity shops than food shops. It used to be the other way around. I lived in the USA for many years and the one thing I hated was the chain superstores because they had no butchers, no bakers, no greengrocers, no independent restaurants. The choice and quality was sadly lacking as there is a limit to ones choices. Even if one pays a little more to shop with a small trader you have to realise that quality of life and products is far better than quantity of products. I for one will be very sad if yet another supermarket comes to town and closes another butcher / greengrocer and possible a baker. It will be a sad day for me and also for the community Mark Ingle
  • Score: 1

6:35am Sat 19 Jul 14

Mark Ingle says...

During my lifetime I have seen all of the supermarkets come to Ludlow and each one has destroyed small businesses to the extent that ludlow now has more charity shops than food shops. It used to be the other way around.
I lived in the USA for many years and the one thing I hated was the chain superstores because they had no butchers, no bakers, no greengrocers, no independent restaurants. The choice and quality was sadly lacking as there is a limit to ones choices.
Even if one pays a little more to shop with a small trader you have to realise that quality of life and products is far better than quantity of products.
I for one will be very sad if yet another supermarket comes to town and closes another butcher / greengrocer and possible a baker. It will be a sad day for me and also for the community and the Ludlow I love.
During my lifetime I have seen all of the supermarkets come to Ludlow and each one has destroyed small businesses to the extent that ludlow now has more charity shops than food shops. It used to be the other way around. I lived in the USA for many years and the one thing I hated was the chain superstores because they had no butchers, no bakers, no greengrocers, no independent restaurants. The choice and quality was sadly lacking as there is a limit to ones choices. Even if one pays a little more to shop with a small trader you have to realise that quality of life and products is far better than quantity of products. I for one will be very sad if yet another supermarket comes to town and closes another butcher / greengrocer and possible a baker. It will be a sad day for me and also for the community and the Ludlow I love. Mark Ingle
  • Score: -1

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree